French
Treats
IN France, Thomas Paine earlier had joined with
Washington, Hamilton, Madison, and select other Americans
declared as French citizens by the Assembly. In September
of 1792, four French departments elected "Citizen Paine"
to the Convention, where he sat for the Pas de Calais
district.
Paine soon allied with the dominant Girondist party of
educated, prosperous, moderate republicans &endash; who
spoke English. Paine did not speak French, so his
speeches were read by translators lacking his flair for
words. Rendered ineffective in the Assembly, his
temperament strained his relations. Among his close
friends stood the Marquis de Condorcet along with Nicolas
de Bonneville, a freemason joining Paine in the Craft.
Paine wrote about freemasonry favoring democracy,
separating church and state.
Draconian Jacobite radicals had seized power early in
the French revolution. Moderate Girondists split off and
asserted restraint. Girondists fell from power by trying
to avoid the beheading of King Louis XVI.
At the climactic trial, Paine recommended imprisoning
the king until war with England was over, then banishing
him for life. Paine was forgiven as a humanitarian Quaker
who, of course, was opposed to the death penalty.
After Louis' head fell into a basket, a mob under Jean
Paul Marat on 2 June 1793 circled the French National
Convention, demanding swift surrender of 29 Girondists.
When Charlette Corday murdered Marat, more waves of
executions followed. Outside Paris, Girondists joined the
royalists in a revolt that was brutally crushed by the
Jacobites.
Paine ceased attending the Assembly when the
Girondists fell. Retreating with friends to rural
Faubourg St. Denis, he dwelled there in peace. But then
the Assembly stripped away his French citizenship, which
deprived him of membership in the Convention, which
erased his legal immunity.
A French law allowed citizens of nations at war with
France to be arrested. Since France was a war with
England, outlawed Englishman Thomas Painewas arrested by
the Jacobins behind the Reign of Terror. The man who
inspired the American revolution that had inspired the
France Revolution was imprisoned without trial in France
for the crime of being British.
Scheduled for execution, Paine was saved by a fluke of
fate (or divine intervention). He'd fallen ill from
prison conditions, according to apocraphal reports, and a
doctor was visiting him in his cell when guards passed to
mark with chalk the doors of those slated to die on the
busy guillotine. Since Paine's cell door was open, the
harried guard placed the chalk mark on the inside panel
of the door. With the door closed after the doctor's
left, the execution mark was hidden from sight. The next
morning, other guards bypassed his cell when collecting
that day's harvest of death, so Paine survived. Somehow,
the mistake was overlooked (theories abound about how or
why), and Paine's accuser, Robespierre, seemed content
with letting Paine endure the pain of imprisonment.
Paine suspected he was denounced at the secret behest
of American minister to France G. Morris, a Tory who'd
voiced personal offense at Paine's "bohemian" ways.
What's documented is that Paine applied for legal
protection as an American citizen. The French foreign
minister received a letter from Morris denying any and
all responsibility for Paine since he had became a French
citizen.
Morris wrote Jefferson that even if America
acknowledged Paine as a citizen, he still was liable
under French law for acts done in France. Paine was safer
sitting quietly in jail, he argued, rather than risking
the guillotine in a boisterous public trial.
Many enemies of the Revolution never went to trial,
Paine among them. Locked in Luxemborg prison, he
eventually persuaded his jailers to provide pen, ink and
paper. He wrote there a portion of The Age of
Reason. One can imagine that his mood was bitter as a
"prisoner of conscience," and this feeling likely
affected the tone of his writing.
The final fall of Robespierre in November 1794 saved
the Girondists from annihilation. Washington's recently
appointed minister to France, James Madison, at long last
claimed Paine as an American citizen, demanding his
freedom.
After nearly a year in a cold and infested prison,
Paine at age 57 emerged weak from illness. He again was
penniless. James Monroe sheltered Paine while his health
returned, but he would never recover his full vigor.
French citizenship was restored to Paine along with a
seat in the Convention in July 1995. He rose in the
French Assembly to declare his faith in the Rights of
Man.
Living thereafter in or near Paris with moderate
republican friends, Paine dedicated his free energy to
organizing a society he called the "Theophilanthropists,"
devoted to supplanting Christian faith with an orderly
deist sense of the universe.
Writing remained Paine's source of livelihood. He
published Dissertation on First Principles of
Government in 1795, then Agrarian Justice in
1797. Between these two, he published his Letter to
George Washington, blaming Morris for plotting his
imprisonment. The harsh claim of conspiracy severely
damaged Paine's public reputation in America. Meanwhile,
he completed and published his critique of religion,
The Age of Reason, with part I in 1794 and part II
in 1796. "I believe in one God, and no more," he begins,
"and I hope for happiness beyond this life."
Paine was a deist, never an atheist as many modern
skeptics and freethinkers mistakenly claim. The Age of
Reason plainly offers Paine's metaphysical spiritual
beliefs. God is the First Cause and Designer of the
universe. God is knowable through the sciences and
through mathematics, through human reason and natural
intelligence. Knowing God directly through his heart and
transcendent spirit also interested Paine, but as a man
of the mind, any certainty about God had to came through
his use of reason.
Christians do not attempt to know God in a reasonable
way, Paine wrote. The Bible is rife with glaring
inconsistencies, subject to many differing
interpretations, and therefore fallible. He compared the
mythology of the Trinity with the paternity of Zeus,
still a provocative analogy. Having dispensed with
Christianity, Paine spoke again about his deist God as
the power and the wisdom anyone can witness directly in
nature. He wrote that God is evident "in the immensity of
the creation, ...in the unchangeable order by which the
incomprehensible is governed."
.